MormonLeaks' Claims of Investigative Journalism

Last June I wrote an article on this blog entitled "Information Is Only Worth It's Context".  This was in reference to MormonLeaks and their "investigative reporting" of 13 LLCs, holding positions of approximately $32 billion in stocks for the Mormon church.  As I indicated then, this was a non-story.  The simple fact is that the Mormon church invests revenues from it's profit-generating businesses wisely.  If the team at MormonLeaks had taken as much time to actually investigate the details as they had "uncovering" the story (ie researching the publicly available SEC Form 13Fs) , they would have learned that in general, the holding companies were organized in such a way as to track portfolios by sector/industry.

 Side note- this information wasn't the windfall of some leak or the work of an intrepid, enterprising gumshoe reporter.  Ryan McKnight, director of MormonLeaks and the Truth and Transparency Foundation, is a practicing accountant and used his industry knowledge to easily find this publicly available data.

Six weeks ago, on February 4th, McKnight and the Truth and Transparency Foundation struck another journalistic goldmine.  The story is a what-not-to-do of terrible journalism.  From all but doxxing a victim of child sexual abuse, to apparently encouraging the victim to surreptitiously record a conversion with his abuser (it seems covert recordings are a favorite tool of  TTF's reporters), to just plain terrible writing (McKnight awkwardly describes the sexual abuse as "penile contact").

McKnight, Ethan Dodge, and the Truth and Transparency Foundation have been less than transparent about their motives.  Their stated goal is to "to promote transparency" through, among other things:"whether supported by their sources' documents or not", investigating and reporting on "problems of corruption and abuse within religious institutions".

If they truly aspired to such lofty climes, they would recognize their short comings in their reporting. As a writer, I naturally take offense at such phrases as "penile contact". It's sexual abuse or alleged sexual abuse. As a journalist, I'm appalled at their sloppiness is not even attempting to protect the identity of their source, a victim of a child sex crime.

I've stated in previous writings that while I'm an active and somewhat participating Mormon, I recognize that the institution is deeply flawed. I'm by no means an apologist for the Mormon church. But I expect a true journalist to approach things in a truly journalistic manner. The TTF and MormonLeaks and their sister organizations are nothing more than anti-Mormon propaganda.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Utah Self Defense Laws Enable Modern Day Vigilantism

All Things Good and Pure