Information is Only Worth it's Context
It's been a day or two since I last wrote, mainly because my brain was empty of words and thoughts and things. I feel like this is a good platform for me to practice reporting, seeing as how i fancy myself an aspiring journalist and whatnot. So, to practice and hopefully get exposure to my stories, I'll be occasionally reporting things here, also, as well, in addition.
That brings me to today's topic. Or topics. Maybe I'm over sensitive. Scratch that, I'm definitely over sensitive. But I feel like I'm justified in growing weary of people calling themselves journalists when they provide information without context or story.
On that note, let me provide some of my own context. I believe that large organizations -be they governments, businesses, religions, or institutions of higher learning- should be held accountable to the people or purposes they serve.
I'm a Mormon. Some would probably call me a skeptical Mormon. I find most of the doctrines in Mormonism to be beautiful. The history, on the other hand, is full of some very dark and confusing moments. So I'll be the first to say that Mormonism has it's issues. There's an organization called Mormon Leaks that is obsessed with providing information that a less educated crowd seems to find offensive.
If they read this, they'll call me out. Come at me, I can hold my own. Let me tell you why I take issue with this group and those who play it fast and loose with the term journalism: They provide information with no context and allow the less educated crowd to create the story. I feel like they do this because they know in most cases there's no actual story.
Whistleblowing organizations serve a necessary, noble, and often dangerous purpose. To hold power accountable. Mormon Leaks has leaked information that is indeed newsworthy, and hopefully that information (which actually had a story) will bring about positive and necessary change. I should also point out that the information that was newsworthy and had a story, was leaked and not original work attributable to Mormon Leaks.
The information originally compiled and provided by the organization was simply raw data with no context. Journalism takes the data and tells a story, informing the audience as to it's relevance and importance. Mormon Leaks failed to provide any context. They never told the story. Because there is no story. No laws were broken, no shady business was conducted. No assets were hidden. They did what any enterprise has done, does, and will continue to do.
Does the church need to be completely honest and transparent? Yes. Have they been? I feel that's very much up for debate. But until Mormon Leaks actually reports on the church and provides a story with context, I suggest they find another target with more nefarious dealings. And until they do what journalists do, they should stop calling themselves journalists. Because they keep saying that word. And I don't think it means what they think it means.
That brings me to today's topic. Or topics. Maybe I'm over sensitive. Scratch that, I'm definitely over sensitive. But I feel like I'm justified in growing weary of people calling themselves journalists when they provide information without context or story.
On that note, let me provide some of my own context. I believe that large organizations -be they governments, businesses, religions, or institutions of higher learning- should be held accountable to the people or purposes they serve.
I'm a Mormon. Some would probably call me a skeptical Mormon. I find most of the doctrines in Mormonism to be beautiful. The history, on the other hand, is full of some very dark and confusing moments. So I'll be the first to say that Mormonism has it's issues. There's an organization called Mormon Leaks that is obsessed with providing information that a less educated crowd seems to find offensive.
If they read this, they'll call me out. Come at me, I can hold my own. Let me tell you why I take issue with this group and those who play it fast and loose with the term journalism: They provide information with no context and allow the less educated crowd to create the story. I feel like they do this because they know in most cases there's no actual story.
Whistleblowing organizations serve a necessary, noble, and often dangerous purpose. To hold power accountable. Mormon Leaks has leaked information that is indeed newsworthy, and hopefully that information (which actually had a story) will bring about positive and necessary change. I should also point out that the information that was newsworthy and had a story, was leaked and not original work attributable to Mormon Leaks.
The information originally compiled and provided by the organization was simply raw data with no context. Journalism takes the data and tells a story, informing the audience as to it's relevance and importance. Mormon Leaks failed to provide any context. They never told the story. Because there is no story. No laws were broken, no shady business was conducted. No assets were hidden. They did what any enterprise has done, does, and will continue to do.
Does the church need to be completely honest and transparent? Yes. Have they been? I feel that's very much up for debate. But until Mormon Leaks actually reports on the church and provides a story with context, I suggest they find another target with more nefarious dealings. And until they do what journalists do, they should stop calling themselves journalists. Because they keep saying that word. And I don't think it means what they think it means.
Comments
Post a Comment